Today’s municipalities don’t lack data; in fact, modern technologies provide scads of it. The key to effective utility management has become analyzing and assessing that information and using it to make critical operating and maintenance decisions. As municipal budgets continue to diminish and expectations continue to increase, municipalities have been creating tactical sewer asset management plans to better support their workloads. Such has been the case for the City of Vista Wastewater Division.
Located just seven miles inland of the Pacific Ocean in northern San Diego County, the City of Vista, Calif. spans approximately 19 square miles and contains a population of 101,797. The 18-person wastewater division is in charge of inspecting and maintaining 316 miles of sewer infrastructure. The City of Vista’s Sewer Division is amongst the top of its class, and it has won many awards and accolades from the California Water Association, including 2nd-place in the Best Medium-sized System category (2011) and Collection System Person of the Year (2014). It also has the numbers to prove that it’s one of the most effective and proactive wastewater management programs in the country. In fact, its sanitary sewer overflow (SSO) ratio is less than 1%, while the average nationwide is over 5%.
In 2015, the City of Vista started the planning and implementation of a sewer asset management program. Prior to the development of this program the City televised its system and then sent data to an outside partner for analysis to develop a 5-year CIP program. However, the City was still unable to use that data to develop an operations and maintenance program. “We knew that we had a goldmine of data that could provide valuable insight on our operations and maintenance,” says Chris Dzwigalski, City of Vista’s Wastewater Operations Supervisor. “We were basically making decisions on the fly, without any true analysis of where our efforts were most needed. We needed a program in place in order to stay ahead.” Since implementing the sewer asset management system the City of Vista has been able to focus resources on the highest risk issues. Having an achievable plan, an engaged staff and effective tools are all essential to implementing a sewer asset management plan.
The Tools For Success
The first step the City took into creating and implementing their sewer asset management plan was to make sure they had the right tools in place to ensure their success. “Without the right equipment our operators can’t collect the data we need to make strategic decisions,” says Dzwigalski. “A critical part of buying the right tools is making sure that our operators feel as though the tools make their job easier, whether it is coding defects, lowering a crawler in a manhole, or post-cleaning inspection using a video nozzle.”
The City of Vista has relied on Envirosight’s equipment to inspect their sewer infrastructure for a long time. They own a sewer inspection truck, two Supervision sewer inspection crawlers to inspect pipes, four Jetscan video nozzles to assess pipes post-cleaning, a few Quickview airHD zoom cameras to quickly assess manholes and a Verisight push camera for inspecting problematic laterals. “All of our equipment works together to create the data we need to make strategic decisions. Envirosight’s equipment has been nothing but dependable and adaptable. Our operators enjoy using it because it is very manageable and user-friendly, and its profile and weight make it easy to use out in the field.
“Our operators and management team liked our Envirosight equipment so much so that we turned to our local Envirosight salesperson Chuy Vallejo at Haaker Equipment when we needed to upgrade our sewer asset management software,” adds Dzwigalski. They needed GIS functionality and WinCan seemed like the perfect sewer asset management suite for their needs. “WinCan was a welcome addition to our sewer asset management toolbox, the interface makes it easy for our operators code inspections quickly unlike our old system.”
Cost Savings Using A Risk-based Approach
“Incorporating an asset management program into our master planning has helped us balance our workload in terms of service, cost and risk,” says Dzwigalski. “We take all the data our sewer inspection equipment collects and import into a custom-built software solution to get data-driven decisions.” Vista has shifted from inspecting its whole infrastructure on an unattainable 5-year cycle to a data-driven 5-10-15 year program. Prior to the 5-10-15 year program the City was inspecting and cleaning 200,000 ft of pipe a year. This change has not only resulted in significant cost savings but also allows the City of Vista staff to focus on CIP projects and other operations and maintenance issues that used to fall by the wayside.
Prior to the implementation of the sewer asset management plan the City was losing operators who were frustrated with the division’s unattainable inspection and cleaning goals. Often operators knew that the pipe they were working on didn’t require any maintenance, but they still had to meet goals. “Implementing an asset management program has engaged our utility staff in ways we never thought possible,” says Dzwigalski. He attributes this change to the increased communication and transparency between the operations and engineering departments. Both staffs now work together on identifying risk thresholds and renewal decision-making processes for condition rehabilitation and inspection frequencies. “Operators now report that they feel as though their jobs are more meaningful,” says Dzwigalski. “The risk-based approach to operations and maintenance activities engages staff to take more ownership of the program, and they see the benefits of the work they perform and a clear strategic plan forward using the information they are collecting.”
Into the Future
The importance of strategic sewer asset management plans will continue to grow as infrastructure ages. As municipalities prepare for the future they are taking a look inward to ensure they are making the best use of the data they are collecting. The City of Vista’s Sewer Asset Management Plan has been able to improve asset management efforts across the board—from a more attainable sewer inspection plan, to complete identification of attributes using GIS, to prioritization of maintenance, to cost reductions on capital improvement plans, to a more engaged crew and more.
To learn more about the City of Vista’s and to read the City’s sewer asset management plan visit: http://www.cityofvista.com/services/city-departments/engineering/construction-projects/sewer. To request a free ROVVER X in-field demo and learn what it can do for your sewer inspection workflow visit: